
Instead of following a war-movie kind of arch rising and falling upon some critical battle or change, instead there is a situational consistence here in the fact that any given day can be life or death. These soldiers do not have one defining moment that changes their lives for better or worse. Each day is a battle, and their heroism is counting out their days trying to get the job done without dying. The film isn't political. It's not a commentary on the state of modern war or the particular conflict going on in Iraq. The point here is much more centered upon these men and their day to day lives at war.
Director Katheryn Bigelow masters a distinctive style without allowing the style to overwhelm the experience. The shaky camera will remind you of the urgency of the situation without giving you a headache because of the nonstop movement. The style suits, but does not overshadow, the story. Of course, "story" here is used loosely. I found myself sidetracked in the middle of the film trying to figure out where, if anywhere, the plot of this film was headed. I kept waiting for the moment when everything would click into focus around something. There is enough of the Hollywood war formula left in this film to expect that sort of resolution--like characters who show up for the clear purpose of dying. The structure wasn't what I initially wanted out of it, but I was plenty satisfied. The ending brings the film into focus just enough to leave me with something to think about.
This is one of the most unique and memorable war films I've ever seen. It's not uplifting. It's not life-changing. It just caught my attention.

Unfortunately, all this set up comes to nothing. I don't want to watch Batman kill machines. I'm much more interested in people full of life and emotion resisting their control, but Bale's bat growl and motorcycle stunts only recall the cold, detached personna of Batman, which does not belong in a Terminator movie. I blame the filmmakers for this more than Bale, as his character was clearly written to be hard and unrelenting. The man/machine hybrid character was much more dynamic. I cared about the fate of Marcus, but in the end, none of the questions were really answered and it didn't really matter.
